Manhattan Joe's Pizzeria - Polo Club

Great pizza and calzone

Great pizza. No Miami flop, a nice thin slice, firm, crunchy pizza. Great flavor, I’d like to see a little more sauce on the slice but overall great eat. The owners wife is a nice New York lady. Love her personally, hard worker, very clean pizzeria. Highly recommend.

One of the better NY style pizzas you will find in the area. Not greasy at all, great slightly dark undercarriage, perfect cheese to sauce balance. Delivered warm in less than 40 mins. Recommended.

Even though a lot of NY transplants come to Florida and open up Pizza shops here in south Florida they just can’t seem to get it right. Manhattan Joe’s is as close as you can get to NYC style pizza. The Ingredients are fresh and cooked to perfection daily. The slices are crispy and the cheese isn’t oily. I love coming here for lunch Atleast 3 days a week. You gotta come here to try it. You won’t be disappointed.

Basic plain pie, football style. Very doughy and a bit undercooked crust and undercarriage. Flavor was bland

Who the fuck is Frankie?

The box says “Hot Delicious Pizza”. At first glance, it looks like it’s in the 7’s...Don’t judge a book by its cover. It wasn’t even warm. Completely undercooked undercarriage. I’ve had this pizza several times over the years. This particular pie was by far not their best.

Tons of flop and lots of grease. I could have made grease soup after. Good taste. Would be good for a late night snack.

Major flop but great sauce

Picked up three large pizzas last night. This is what's left. Excellent thin and crispy pizza. They take pride when making pizzas.

Cheese is amazing, I love that is really crispy, the crust is pretty amazing too and just a bit greasy but still amazing. Def deserves a 8.4👍

Burned top of my mouth, happens to the best of us. Little greasy but not too bad. Great crust, no flop and really crisp which I like.

Half Margherita. Half Plain Cheese. Well done. Light on cheese. Too much sauce.

Dana gives it an 8.5!!

Good appearance. Looks like a classic slice. Missing that special taste.

Nice crispy crust, right amount of sauce with nice flavor. Has a good hold to the fold. The first reviewer obviously hasn’t had good pizza before. One of my goto spots.