Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant

Extreme salt alert. This is a salt explosion. Dough - the saltiness of the regular football slice was so salty, I immediately pulled off a tiny piece of dough at the edge to find the culprit. After all, it logically would have to be the sauce or cheese. IT’S THE DOUGH! In over 350 reviews, I’ve never tasted dough like this. Alone, with no other ingredients, it’s actually not terrible. It tastes like a Philly soft pretzel. However, combined with other ingredients it overwhelms everything. Cheese - acceptable chew but demolished by salty dough so taste unclear. Sauce - unclear, annihilated by salty dough Execution - great bake, very nice crunch, absolutely staggering salt bomb taste Ratio- fine Itzhak Perlman said, “There is a long road to travel from playing notes as written, perfectly, and making music.” Bonus margherita score 4.9 Same issue - salt bomb Regardless of whether this was an accident and a one off mistake in the dough, or it’s always this salty, either way, it speaks volumes about this place. It’s inexcusable to let a product out the door like this. Great pizza dough tastes somewhat like bread, not a salty Philly soft pretzel However, ideal for Knicks fans after having your heart stomped on by your absurdly inconsistent team. A great place to meet to decide your next scam, robbery or heist to acquire the necessary dollars for tickets to the next game.

Alright

6.7 on the triangle slice, 7.3 on the smaller square, 7.0 on the big square, averaging out to a 7.0. 3 different tasting pizzas despite the fact that they pretty much are the same slices.

Ok pizza, nothing to write home about

More like a Margherita/Gma but still really good

Very good pizza and amazing sauce very thin

Good football pizza

Nasty pizza.

Didnt taste like much of anything, had better frozen pizza

Good Quality, Hometown Football pizza. Wish it was a little more on the crispy side, the middle of the pie tends to flop hard; But has great flavor. Sauce has a nice tang, cheese is good, crust and dough tastes good as well. Would eat again

“1 plain, not too crispy.” Yes, a GREAT NYC slice!! Perfect flop with the perfect dough consistency; chewy, light, & airy. The ideal sauce to cheese ratio, that’s sweet & stretchy! 🍕

This pizza wouldn’t be worth it if it wasn’t for the crust, nice and crispy but still has a softness to it, the sauce has an Italian taste to it but unfortunately it doesn’t overpower the blandness of the cheese

Love the original slice they have .... when you eat one you cant stop... its nice and thin and light

Located in the heart of downtown Hightstown, Mannino’s 4! not too sure where the other 3 went but this slice is out of this world! the sauce is the perfect amount of tang and the crust has the perfect crunch, the only thing not making this a 9 is it doesn’t have the traditional jersey flop, overall though a top quality slice.

Wonderful plain slice, good cheese-to-sauce ratio and great crust. Bathroom is a little sketch, but overall functioning. Mannino's IV is a great stop for football slices, plenty of good specialty slices available too.

Our go to for solid pizza. Very good pie. Plain pie is what barstool would define as football pizza. Just all around good slice. I’d give the grandma and specialty pies in the 8’s. Good sauce, not greasy.