Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

OK, here. We are on a cloudy day. It’s a Thursday, had to take mom to the doctor all the way in Smithtown. We figured we’d get a pizza review in. Going on our annual fishing trip tonight. Hopefully we catch some big stripers. Have this place got pretty decent reviews, and Mom says it’s good. And the plane slices look really good as well. Let’s jump in. Very good Long Island pizza. It is a tad doughy, but still very good. Good crisp, great taste. Football pizza.

Nice crust and sauce. The white was better than the pepperoni.

Solid pizza discovered the White Slice in Long Island and have been craving it ever since.

Burn your face off hot. $7 cash for 2 slices is fair pricing. Square slice is thick but crispy. Fresh cheese with good pull but not too much sauce. Regular slice was more sauce heavy but still really good. Nice spices to it. I would come back if in the area.

Taste was very good. Sicilian had no crunch, very doughy. Fresh ingredients

Decent Sicilian slice. Sauce was open on point. Could have been served hotter.

Good basic slice, little flop

Floppy, soggy, soft, slightly with flavor... not as good as I remember...

Tasty slice good sauce

I always like this place. It’s nothing if it’s not consistent, and it’s usually pretty good.

Average ~ super flop. No crunch at all. Fresh ingredients. This slice looks a mess... but to be fair I went and got a slice for lunch and forgot to take a pic... that slice looked normal. When I went out for dinner I went to another place down the road and actually stopped in again for the pic! THAT’S how devoted I am to the game ay oh!!

Great sauce flavor, but a little bland cheese. Very good overall slice.

8.1 regular 9.0 rookie score buffalo. We're going even Stevens 8.6