3,264 views•218 likes
matthew.koons9/2/22, 9:02 p.m.
There is Manco and Manco at OCNJ. Then there’s Marcello’s (Sally Slices) in Hamilton Square. Heaven. On. Earth.
ameo317/12/22, 5:18 p.m.
Slices were a cross between a Sicilian and tradition Brooklyn style. Sauce was just okay but the cheese was great and the pepperoni was perfect. Decent pepperoni roll as well.
adam.sammy10/10/21, 4:25 p.m.
I follow Sal on Instagram and the pizza always looks good so being 15 minutes away had to give it a go. Great undercarriage, crispy edges, delicious sauce. It definitely has a tang to it and makes the pie what it is. Would definitely get it again when in the area.
brandon.hardman19/28/21, 3:33 p.m.
The Corleone style is amazing! It’s a cross between Detroit and Sicilian style pizza with an almost focaccia like crust. Everything about this pizza we different and delicious. Drove two hours for this pizza and will do it again! Only the best!
ja420ck9/19/21, 10:32 p.m.
Corleone pie. ive had this before its around the corner from me. apparently its popular on tiktok now idk still havent seen them. Sauce could be more consistent. The crispy lace around the crust is the best part. The undercarriage is a little too spongy but still liked it.
reezyree409/18/21, 6:59 p.m.
After watching the numerous tik toks from the man Sallyslices had to stop in myself and try the infamous “Corleone Pizza.” Let me start out by saying this is a different style of pizza that I am usually not use to but change is good. My first bite of the pizza made me think that this pizza was maybe a 6.8 but after truly eating the next slice I started to get a better grasp on the slice. Once my taste buds got acclimated to the pizza I fell in love with it. Crispy Crust with a softer inside with various cheeses and a rich fine sauce increased my rating up to 7.6-7.8 range. Honestly a very good tasting type of pizza that I know down the line I will crave again.
mrkoppenhaver5/10/21, 11:13 p.m.
Marcello's makes "Corleone" style pizza. It is a square pillow from heaven. It is a thick fluffy dough with a huge crisp on the bottom. The sause is amazing. I'd eat the sauce off a flip flop. I shot a review for my YouTube page then the workers invited me in for pictures. They didn't know I was nobody special but hey it was fun feeling famous for a second. I will be traveling across Hamilton from now on just to get this pizza!
lennoll14/20/21, 10:33 p.m.
The Corleone pie is the specialty here. Baked in a rectangular pan, seems like a cross-over between a Detroit style and a Sicilian. Nice crispy bottom, good but a bit bland overall. The sausage is a bonus, but can’t rate that, right?
chris.jf074/7/21, 5:14 p.m.
Really liked their Corleone’s Style Pizza! It had a nice crisp and very good flavor. Definitely would go back again!
aaronpinto1/24/21, 12:06 a.m.
Reviewing their Corleone-style pizza as that appears to be what they’re known for. Well above-average Sicilian pizza, basically. Very crispy. Great seasoning. Gets the job done.