Maria’s Pizza

Very floppy, tastes pretty good, sauce isn’t as tangy as others.

Crust was cooked perfectly. Sauce is a little sweet and the pepperoni has a little kick to it. One of the best pizzas in Milwaukee.

Amazing pizza and one of the best I ever had. Sauce and sausage tasted amazing. Only the crust (which was a bit soggy) and extra grease keeps this pie out of the 9’s.

This place is delicious and a benchmark pizza for sure. Super thin, excellent crisp, and perfect sauce.

Great crust

This Pizza is pure perfection, there is nothing else quite like it. Always fantastic quality served by great people!

Great place, you know it's good when they have been around for 60 years, CASH ONLY. Great thin crust with great undercarriage and char. Sauce could be better but still good.

Tasty but greasy

Awesome pizza. Good balance of sauce to cheese to toppings. Crisp crust with a little char, and the sauce has an awesome acidic tang. Plus the place is just old school awesome, cash only which bumps the score up.

This is the best place in Milwaukee and its not even close. I’m Italian from Chicago .., I’ve had the best from down there Aurelio’s, Palermo’s. How this place is a 7.5 when you consider some scores on adjacent places is beyond me. They do a good job cooking the pizza and it has a good sauce. The sauce here is what GOOD sauce is supposed to taste like. The sauce has 100 times the depth of flavor of dicarlos

Why 9.3? Simple, if I have to choose 1 pizza to eat for the rest of my life, it is this one.

Tangy sauce which is a plus. Place only accepts cash which knocks the rating down.

It was cold and not cut with flavor.