Order now on Slice
Order Mario's NY Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
floridascott11/29/21, 6:53 a.m.
I came here for 2 reasons. One by recommendation in a late night bar and also, by seeing the most perfect name for a pizza place on the Florida West Coast. 1. Weak, by all standards. Very doughy, no seasoning, not very photogenic. 2. Place was pretty slow with no one in there. 3. I grant you that some people may like the place, because I learnt from the past, people may like basic unseasoned food. 4. My rating is 6.6
tumbleweed7/8/20, 5:34 p.m.
No flop👍🏻, nice crisp.👍🏻 Cheese was mediocre 👎🏻 sauce was just ok but the crust was actually good in consistency and flavor. Try the garlic knots👍🏻👍🏻 this pizza would benefit from better cheese like bacio cheese, the pepperoni tasted cheap.
macho_the_man5/8/19, 3:35 p.m.
Call it a rookie score if you need to but it was on the fence and I just felt it didn’t deserve to start with a 6. Cheese slice-it was a good slice. Nice crisp, good sauce to cheese ratio. Not too much grease. Wish it had just a little more zip or tang to to it but overall good. Bonus slice- this was called “the butcher”. Jam packed with meats and melted cheese not only was the crust thicker to support the weight of the toppings but it had 0 flop. Again nice crisp. Flavors were good again just didn’t have that pop. It’s missing something.
shawncarr85/6/19, 6:08 p.m.
Good pie. First slice had 2 inch flop. Not a lot of grease, second slice had a decent amount of flop. Good drinking pizza. If I’m in the area and craving pizza, i would come back. Wouldn’t drive 30 min plus.
drew.douglass4/29/19, 10:17 p.m.
Some of the best Pizza in St. Pete. Get the white pizza with tomatoes.