Mario's Pizza

Non traditional, garlic/spinach white pie. Great undercarriage and flavor is out of the world. My go to slice. Other slices here are equally as good and the family has owned it forever. They are not closed as the app says.

We got a couple of requests to try this pizza place in Port Ewan. The plain slices, even though the cheese and sauce didn’t taste bad. However, I feel like the crust isn’t crispy enough, so it’s average for me. The Sicilian slice has a sweet sauce and it’s a killer for me. Sicillian slice: 6.2 Michael’s rating: 7.1 Sicillian slice: 6.3

Pretty soupy. Decent flavor.

Flop was solid, but not enough bbq flavor.

Excellent pizza. Slight NY flop. Great crust. Good amount of cheese. It's usually not good delivery or take out. Very soggy. Recommend to eat inside like I did today. *Got a 12 inch pizza without tomato Sauce. Allergic to tomatoes.*

Mario’s Pizza - Kingston, NY