Martellucci's Pizzeria

Classic for at least 50!years.

Lehigh University 🏈 Alert Community score is a bit generous but the people are absurdly nice so blasting the place is pointless Ratio - too cheesy Execution - ok Cheese - pleasant taste and chew Sauce - a bit of spice, nice job Dough - adequate taste and crunch Mets fans are forbidden to come here. In fairness, it’s hard to find, and on your rotary dial cell phone with no internet access, you have no gps anyway Gershwin said, “Jazz is the result of the energy stored up in America.”

This pie is kind of unique. The crust is thin doughy, I would have liked a little crisp. It was heavy handed on the cheese. Surprising not much flop but the sauce is very delicious. 3 more minutes in the oven and this would be close to an 8 for me. The staff was very friendly, cute place and close to home. I would go back and ask for well done!

Old school Neighborhood pizza joint, very good crust, zesty sauce, cheesy

Relatively standard slice that’s thin, but not paper thin. Tasted a little garlic. They have a good deal they run daily - two slices and a fountain drink for $6. Friendly staff too.

Always good for the 2 for $5 deal. Solid slices, soft undercarriage.

Really good, thin, good crisp, could be a little more well done but other than that, best pizza I’ve had in Bethlehem

Ordered well done. Nice and thin with good sauce and cheese. A little flop and a little crisp. Also had a thin crust Sicilian. Good also with good sauce/cheese ratio with nice undercarriage.

The cheese pizza had a good crispy crust and sauce had a little tang. Cheese was basic, but a solid slice. The thin style Sicilian was basically the same too. Probably should have gotten the thick Sicilian.

Double slice and a water The slices were from a new pie, flop but a good tang and some basil in the sauce very nice cracker crust, enjoyed the atmosphere and the slices you should too.

Very very good slice, the crust boosted it from a 7.7 to 8.1

Large plain pie. On the small side for a large. Crust thin and crispy edges- fantastic! Some flop. Plenty of cheese- little greasy. Sauce was very good. Overall a very solid pie. Just wish it was bigger.

Great looking well done pie right? No, it’s a disappointing imposter that has us puzzled. The bottom is soft and undercooked? Could be baked in a pan? If only the bottom was crispy it would a much higher score

Solid Pie! Thinner crust, crispy, extra cheese... solid pizza and an awesome family!

Superior thin crust, fluffy under the toppings but crunchy around the ends. Very delicious sauce and cheese combo.. out of this world slice.

Excellent sauce, cheese and crispy thin crust. So good

Good pie Crust is great with a great crunch. The sauce and cheese taste great. The body of the pie is a bit doughy and thick for my liking. If they rolled the dough thinner and had it crispy like the crust it would be and 8.1, 8.2 pie.

*EDIT* This is the second time reviewing this pie. I have drastically changed my opinion. This is a uniquely delicious offering and deserves more respect than the previous review. If you're in the Bethlehem area, you must try it!

Nicely cooked but still a little doughy. Crispy crust, tang is mild. Overall, solid taste

Awesome sauce, great thin crust.

Gift from Julie I was reeeally impressed, very cheesy and relatively light crust, would definitely get again one of the best in the area

Pretty good.

This pizza exceeded expectations for me. Cheese was so good (I got extra) great taste. Got thin crust Sicilian as well.