Marty's Pizza - Delafield

Sauce and undercarriage are on point

Relaxing family friendly atmosphere. Polite staff. The cheese curd and garlic bread were great, the pizza was even better. Great cheese and sauce. Crunchy crust, pull apart cheese.

This was my first time here and I was surprised by the square pizza. Don’t know if this is a thing for the 10” only or if all their pies are square. Was decent overall. Cracker style crust with a good amount of sauce. Honestly the score would have been higher if I would have grabbed a slice from the right side first. The left side wasn’t as done underneath so it lacked crisp but once I grabbed a slice on the right the crisp was to the moon! 6.8 first bite but could have been 7.1. Luck of the slice draw.

Pretty decent pie! Reminded me of a “post game pizza place” you go to after a little league game or something. Cheese and sauce were both good. Nice crunch but the dough is a little chalky.

First bite was the best bite! Not too greasy, GREAT crunch! A little powdery but very good.

Perfect amount of cheese with a sweeter sauce! The crust was nice and firm, with outsides being the crispiest. We got it for take out. I will have to try eating it right out of the oven!

I’ve had this pizza a couple times not by choice and it’s average.

Good, real good.

Awesome Marty's all meat pizza, this will satisfy all your lunch cravings!

Delicious sauce. Very good

Good sauce, good crust. Good pie.

Tangy sauce, crispy crust. Sausage is perfect. Always have a good pizza here.