Got the Tomato Pie. Sauce, sausage and basil were tasty. The crust was a bit bland. Almost reminded me of frozen pizza crust. 😳
Order now on Slice
Order Mateo's Tomato Pie & Restaurant
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
farpieog9/11/22, 1:05 p.m.
Wow wow a hidden gem in an area w not a lot of good pizza. This tomato pie is what anyone could ever ask for. Great crust under carriage no flop w a great sauce cheese ratio. Totally legit this guy knows food. Homemade soups amazing all around food as good and affordable as you could ask for. I really hope Dave never goes here..or maybe I do family place and he would blow up w a Dave Review. I’ve eaten a lot of pizza in my life and this is some of the best. Eat it at the place
stevieslice8/7/22, 1:15 a.m.
This is very good pizza. I had the mateos special and a slice of tomato pie. Both were really strong. Good undercarriage and the ingredients were strong. I would go back.
mike.schimenti7/21/22, 11:22 p.m.
Gave it a try since it was on the way to the beach…. I would go INSANELY out of my way to get this again. Go with the Trenton-style tomato pie over the plain. Very similar to Delorenzo’s and it was almost as good.
brian.a.6/1/22, 10:30 p.m.
The tomato pie is easily the best pizza in the area. Lite and crispy. Sauce has some sweetness. Great cheese. Reminds me of Angelos on 9th. Seems like a new place ,but has family vibes.