About Matthew's Pizza
493 Yelp Reviews
justin.turner10/15/21, 4:44 p.m.
Pan pizza with a lot of grease; cooked well. Decent crunch. I ordered mine with mozzarella cheese as opposed to reggianito, but apparently, it’s better with both.
rockylemon9/9/21, 3:51 a.m.
Crust 10 Sauce 7 Cheese 7 My 3 scores average out to and eight but I gave it an extra .5 just because this place is a baltimore landmark. The crab pizza is amazing the crust is by far the best crust I've ever had anywhere. I've had all the pizzas sold at the place so I know the sauce is very good and the Cheese is solid as well. For the people that say this is taste like pizza hut you just don't know pizza or if you say this isn't my kind of pizza then why even try it or give a review. Hand down one of the best deep dish anywhere.....
jtm27276/19/21, 12:22 a.m.
Solid pizza in Baltimore. Thicker crust, caramelized cheese has a Detroit style feel to it. Crab pizza was definitely the highlight for me, and preferred margherita to pepperoni. Overall a very good pizza experience.
jimmy.siegert5/1/21, 11:15 p.m.
Here we go with the legendary matthews pizza. Sauce is super fresh the cheese is not too heavy out greasy. Crust is awesome nice and buttery. Great pizza.
subdiver4/18/21, 1:38 a.m.
Deep dish pies, thick, pretty greasy and good. 7.4 for Crab pizza, 7.2 for the Margherita.
brittanyeatsplants1/9/21, 2:03 p.m.
The BEST pizza you can possibly get in Baltimore. Locals know what is up when it comes to Matthews Pizza. The low reviews are probably from out of towners who don’t know what a good pizza is because they are used to sub par joints in their small town. Ask ANY Baltimore local and they will recommend Matthews Pizza
m4ster7/3/20, 6:32 p.m.
This is a Chicago style deep dish pizza joint from the 1940’s. I love deep dish pizza. The 4 cheese pizza at Matthew’s is my favorite pizza in Baltimore. Delicious crispy & charred crust. Excellent cheeses, excellent sauce. Most of the time it’s a little too greasy, but it’s still excellent.
mark.lontok2/22/20, 10:51 p.m.
Bar pizza. Greasy as fuck. Zero flop. It’s like a personal pan from PizzaHut.
nicholas.pace112/16/19, 6:19 p.m.
Not for everyone, especially if you’re looking for a traditional NY slice. But overall a very good slice. Solid 7.6
bryan.smith110/20/19, 2:28 a.m.
Great old time pizza joint. Gave me Pizza Hut vibes. Not bad for a first time visit
lucas.villalobos10/6/19, 10:26 p.m.
One of the best pizzas in Baltimore. The crust is very cheesy and buttery, great cheeses too. No flop since it’s deep dish style. Very old school place which gives the place lots of character.
lightspeednate8/9/19, 10:18 p.m.
They don’t package their pizzas properly. That’s a foul right there! very cheesy, not a ton of sauce. a little bit messy. very bready. Good crisp on the crust. Sadly a little bit reminiscent of grilled cheese. Not a huge fan, but you can tell their pizza is a little more cafully crafted than other Baltimore pizza spots. 6.0
anthony.dimenna8/4/19, 10:52 p.m.
Thick and airy, crispy crust with melted, crunchy cheese. Grated italian cheese, mozzarella, and ricotta with portobello mushrooms and pepperoni. 10 out of 10, best in Baltimore.