Max and Leo's - Newton

Best pizza I’ve ever had

MAX AND LEO’S 8.5 CHEDDAR JACK REVIEW #73

Portnoy not eating toppings really does a disservice to this place. High quality ingredients.

The reason this isn’t a 1 is that my daughter white pizza was about 7.0. I e never seen less care put in to making a pizza in my life. It’s too bad too, as the flavor was there. Bottom completely fought while the edges crisp. FYI, I arrived 6 minutes late, pizza was done and o asked for slightly well done. What a disappointment. The white pizza lacked garlic and was a tad dry…but crust was perfect. Ordered the same time.., how could they be so different?

Good crust

Nice homey feel. Great pizza.

Exceptional slice. Fantastic cheese and crust.

Really good flavor, too doughy.

Solid pie. Consistently good. Always eat in and grab a couple beers…Add the roasted habanero wings for a good 1-2 punch.

Got it to go, a bit chewy but flavorful cheese, fresh sauce and smoky coal fired crust. Probably better if you don’t close the box.

Last year they were an 8.5. Now they've reduced the cheese quality resulting in a greasy af pizza. Shame, still decent because of the coal fire oven. It's really a 7.1 but I'm assessing a 0.2 for foul play.

Good flavor from the sauce, could have used more crisp on the undercarriage. Solid if you in the area.

Seriously good. Thick but light. A little doughy (which I don’t mind) but if you asked for well done this thing could be scraping high 8’s for sure.

Solid pie. Coal fired. To be noted the wings and Mac and cheese were spectacular as well.

The place has a killer wood fire oven! The cheese pizza has a very tangy sauce and a cheese with a really strong aged parmesan flavor. Its definitely different and the crust was tasty I'd give this pie a 7.3 this cheese and sauce combo won't be for everyone...I didn't love it but I can appreciate it...Now the margarita pizza was in my opinion WAY better the sauce was a nice bright tomato sauce with a hint of garlic the cheese was a nice smooth mozzarella with good flavor and it had a crisp crust and was finished with fresh basil this pizza scored at a solid 8.5 It had a ton of great flavor!