Melilli Cafe & Grill

If it had lighter cheese it’d be in the 8s

Really good thin crust pizza. One of the best in the area for sure. Do yourself a favor and get an eggplant parm grinder too. That’s a 9.4. Just really solid, fresh, and well made food.

Solid my thin crust pizza and pizza slices, good crisp on slice due to reheat, nice char on undercarriage, good sauce cheese ratio, sweetish sauce, generous toppings, locals love this place, def check it out if you’re in Middletown/Portland area! Love the brownstone buildings!