Mellow Mushroom Sanford

Always solid from Mellow Mushroom. The crust is always crisp and tasty. Sauce is good not too sweet but could use a little more flavor. The toppings are probably the worst part of the pizza but nothing terrible. The cheese is very good. Overall a solid pizza every time here. Great place to go out to eat as well.

Solid pizza, a little too doughy and sauce is a little thin but solid slice.

More of a specialty pizza than NY style. Crust is like garlic roll which I like for being different. Sauce is good and topping where fresh tasting. Not a 5.8 pizza

Not a new york slice. But, 5.8 in the One Bite app? That is too low. You come here for lots of toppings, dough, and cheese. Also, the pretzel bites are amazing. It’s good pizza, people. And please, don’t get a “personal pie” and judge them on that.

I thought the rating from the community was too low on this. I got the gold standard as always, cheese. Little flop on a medium pizza slice. Very cheesy and they add Parmesan on it (not sure what to think about that). A little doughy and some grease but the slice wasn’t bad. I’d eat here again I just wouldn’t travel more than a few minutes. The price was a little high for some menu items but the cheese was decent.

Not for me.

It’s not horrible