Michelangelo Pizzeria

Really good stuff. The grandmas slice was some of the best on the island. The sauce is so rich, and the parmesan on top gives it a nice touch. Had a regular slice too, very crunchy, and overall tasted very good.

Slice is very hot, so cheese is very soft and slides off. A lot of sauce which is a plus. Sauce is bland, crunch is nice

Way to greasy and not enough tang to the sauce. Not bad, but not good.

The people that work here are very nice and accommodating, that being said the pizza was just ok - no flop but greasy and not a lot of flavor. I’ll go back because of the workers!

Good football pizza. Mattituck flop. Too much grease. Not bad for the North Fork.