Michelino's Pizzeria

Great pizza, good cheese/sauce, no flop!!

I can't get enough of this pizza. I'm on the road every day because of my job, and I eat a lot of different pizzas all over the place, but this one is different. Flavor is one of a kind. Not just best in Rahway, but I say top two in New Jersey. I don't know how this place doesn't have hundreds of reviews. It's right down the street from Nancys. Nacys is good, but this one is definitely better. My recommendation- Large pie well done. You won't be disappointed.

My highest rating ever. This is amazing. The sauce. The flavor. The toppings. Perfection.

I like this pizza. The golden standard has a nice crispiness to it. The flavors are very good. There really isn’t any flavor that overpowers any other flavor and the ingredients play well together. The one area to improve on is the greasiness. Could be part of the flavor, but it does drip from the amount of grease that is on it. This is a great neighborhood. Classic football slice pizzeria. The square slice is a little less desirable in my opinion. It’s not as flavorful as the standard slice. 7.7 on the standard slice and 7.3 on the square.

One of the absolute best I’ve had in NJ! This is in my top 10!

Surprisingly crisp no flop and not doughy. Good crust and good cheese to sauce consistency. Not too oily

Nice

Lots of NY flop which I don’t mind too much lots of grease but decent flavor not bad for NJ pizza would order again well done for some crispy-ness