Middle Island Pizza

Solid pizza.

Pretty average kind of bland

Great crisp to the crust! They use a great sauce!

Good little crisp, overall ok.

Not mad at this place. Good crisp. Tastes fresh.

I’m going to have to agree with the accumulative dozen other reviews from here ~ I think the 6.8 average is pretty spot on. Something about the crust I did like… but 6.8… yeah, sounds right.

Scrumptious sauce these fellas don't fool.around. flavorful sauce good spice and good layer of cheese beautiful underneath. Fluffy crust not my style although can't take much away awesome slice. Vodka sauce on the other slice is best I've ever had if you want something different with knock your socks off flavor vodka sauce fresh mozz pesto drizzle on a crispy crust- Ala vodka margarita got an 8.9.

Unique sauce. Doughy crust. My type of pizza. The best pizza in the area….100%.

Pretty solid. Was thin and crispy and the flavor was decent. A little on the oily side, but well above your average Long Island slice.

Regular pretty crispy. Sauce tastes pretty good. Cheese is ok but gives off alot of grease. Not a bad slice 7.0 Sicilan: it's a thick slice but its cooked well sauce and cheese tastes good. 7.7

If you like a doughy pizza that's light on the sauce and light on the cheese, this place has a slice for you. I do not. Specialties are better.

It’s a good slice. Above average in all facets. There’s better out there, but this slice is worth trying.

Good crust, size good, sauce and cheese subpar, decent slice... it’s football pizza Frankie.

Crust is good. But sauce and cheese leaves a lot to be desired.