Mike and Maggie's Pizzeria

A little greasy with minimal flop. The sauce and cheese were average to good at best with a crust that really had very little taste. If your hungry and in the mood for pizza a decent slice.

Got two pies delivered. Both were fantastic (as always). Perfect cheese/sauce ratio, great crisp and very fresh. This is a small shop with great pizza.

Such a great slice. Best garlic knots I’ve had in a while also! Will definitely be coming back!!!! :)

Honestly one of the best slices i ever had, not to greasey, no flop, crispy and the sauce is just phenomenal

I come back via the cross island every day and took a detour after seeing their good yelp score. In an nutshell, I wasn’t disappointed! Wanted to help this small mom and pop shop out. It’s a quintessential brick oven slice. Sauce is nice and tangy, little to no flop. Delicious.

Best white pie i ever had. Crust was tasty with the right crisp crunch i like. Would definitely go back. Love the home style atmosphere with the variety of music playing. Brought my mama with me and we finished the whole pie.... my new fav is mike and maggies

Great taste and crisp! Sauce is tasty

Oily with no crisp.