I don’t always order pizza, but when I do, it’s always a Sicilian from Mike’s Pie 👌
603pizzaguy1/20/21, 5:04 p.m.
603 Pizza review time! Still searching for that perfect pie in the 603. Can honestly say I was expecting more here based on the reviews. One cheese slice, one Sicilian slice. Cheese slice was a little overcooked,which I like, but crust could have used more crisp and surprisingly lacked flavor. Nice change from Greek style, but expected more, not much flavor, no wow factor here. Sicilian slice had the sweet sauce which was good at first, but became too much for me after a few bites. Didn’t really care for the flatness of the edge crust. However, at 6 bucks, for two slices and a coke, a bargain and will give it another review. 603 search continues!
drewfo4/19/20, 12:06 a.m.
Lowell/Nashua area has some trash pizza for example here's some legacy reviews: Broadway is a 6.7 and Fio's is a 4.3. If I were a local and this was all I knew I could see it pushing a 9. This is easily the best pizza in the area I've had. Good ingredients, actual football pizza and not Greek. But since I've lived South Shore, been to the original Regina, been to Sally's Apizza, I can't justify an 8. Still good. 7.9 baby
klgallagher922/9/20, 1:23 a.m.
Good pizza for New Hampshire. Still no where near New Haven. Super greasy, some good flavors. Not bad at all. Sicilian score 7.2
mike.m112/2/20, 8:15 p.m.
Didn’t have slices when I came so got a small cheese. Nice crunchy crust. Sauce was a little sweet but otherwise a delicious pizza. I need to come back for the Sicilian and I would like to try their regular slice. The more I ate the more this pizza grew on me. Not getting into the 8’s only because I want to try a full slice.
juicepatel12/28/19, 8:48 p.m.
Go with the sweet Sicilian with provolone, ask for it well done. Best sweet slice in this area facts!
edward.garnishment12/9/19, 11:49 p.m.
Sicialian 8.4 regular 7.6. very good sweet sauce regular is ok, 8.0 to even them out
chrismader3010/26/19, 8:17 p.m.
This is a place I occasionally drive out of the way to get pizza from. High quality pie, excellent crust, medium flop, sweet sauce.
lailalikespizza10/26/19, 3:19 a.m.
Average score is super inflated by all the wankster 10 and 9 rookie scores. That being said, the sauce was too sweet for my preference. Very solid cheese to sauce ratio tho and crust was some of the better I’ve had in NH...for what it’s worth. Deducted a little for the poor look. All in all a good pie and interested to try their Sicilian next time
kmpzrev9/20/19, 10:23 p.m.
I saw the reviews and the scores and couldn’t wait to go by and try it. Mikes Pie totally lived up to the hype. Great sauce, cheese and crust. Can’t wait to try the Sicilian next time I’m up in that area.
cvcarson27/21/19, 10:44 p.m.
Great slice. Good amount of cheese, sauce was a bit sweet for my liking, crust was a bit doughy. Sicilian style same score.
pizzafingers6/15/19, 12:40 a.m.
One of the best in the area. Sauce is slightly sweet but not overpowering as the spices and herbs still come through. Cheese is good and it’s melted enough so it’s not just a solid block sitting on the pie. Dough is soft and flavorful with a slight crisp on the outside. Siskel and Ebert would’ve given it Two Thumbs Up.
ryan.lacasse6/9/19, 6:37 p.m.
Hope coming in for the celebrity review and slamming down a strong 9! My personal opinion is 8.7 but that still super good. Here's the spread. The double cheese is uniform and fantastic, crust was crisp with a good structure. Here's the magic although the sauce was a little sweet for me, the pallet of the pie lends its self perfect for adding red pepper, re heating in a fry pan you name it. The versatility and flavor really make a great pizza
40 views•1 like