Mikes Pizza

Ton of hype around this... 1 week lead time and they deliver to the location of their choice. Pizza was good but did not live up to they buildup. Crust was on par, but it was like getting into a $5k score change box for the Super Bowl and only 16 points are scored. To boot you brought your long lost ex girlfriend to the Super Bowl party after connecting on social media. She shows up 60 lbs heavier than the profile picture... At the end of the night, you still crush the pizza.

Sorry guys but didn’t live up to the hype for me. Too much parm on every pie we ordered. A little greasy, floppy, and the crust was a little too chewy for my taste. Not saying it’s bad but I’ve had better

Sauce has a nice kick and the crust is excellent. A bit too cheesey for me though.

I’ve never had such good crust. The cheese to sauce ratio was spot on. I just wasn’t the biggest fan of the little basil things on top and the sauce was a tad to sweet. I would definitely go out of my way to have this place and they’re very low-key. Not very “out there”.

Best Pizza on LI

Too drunk to taste this pizza. It good tho.

Wasnt a fan of the sicilian i had a while back. Finally able to try the regular . Amazing. Old school , brings me back. The calzone is almost a must have

By far, the most addicting and delicious sicilian pie you can get in the NY. All fresh ingredients but, it's the incredible crust that keeps you coming back for more every single time. 😍🍕