Mikey's Late Night Slice

Not bad at all. Quick and easy

Crispy. Great crust & very good undercarriage. Very little Flop or grease. Only things that prevented a 7.8+ was lack of cheese & a bit too much herbs. Overall, very solid.

Really good pizza. Great garlic flavor. Not a fan of the unicorn sauce but that’s just me.

Greasy AF. A little extra for the atmosphere minus the high cost ($6.50) for a slice. Line was out the door. 🍕🍕🍕

Cheese and basil. Very solid pizza.

Nice slice! Good crispy undercarriage!

This pizza is amazing. Best NY slice I’ve had. They say get the unicorn sauce…that’s amazing too but not needed. Well done

You’re drunk. It’s late. Mikey is there for you.

Solid undercarriage. Great flavor and the crunch really is all that. Solid 9.1.

Cheesy, solid crust, decent

Very good all around pizza. Thin and crispy crust. The crust has good flavor and a nice undercarriage. The cheese is good quality and there is a generous amount on the slice. The sauce leaves a little to be desired. I prefer a sweet sauce this is more of a straight tomato light savory flavor.

I’m a month late on this review, but I still remember how much I enjoyed it. The line was out the door! They had so many different options of pizza. Nice thin style.

If you’re in Columbus OH grab a slice from Mickey’s. Absolutely no flop on my slice with a unique flavor with the spices on the pie. Crust is good and there’s plenty of pepperoni on the pie. I would like a little more sauce on the za otherwise a very good pizzza

This was actually a decent slice - Surprising given the poor stigma for Ohio pizza. I enjoyed it. Dipped the pizza “bone” crust in the various sauces - unicorn, ranch, and garlic butter. At 2:00am, this could very well be a straight 10.0. Circumstantially exceptional.

This place is awesome. Great atmosphere. Good pizza. Skip the unicorn sauce - would be better with wings.

All around pretty decent pizza. Good atmosphere for a night out.

Good drunk pizza. Little too much seasoning and a bit greasy but overall not bad.

Pretty decent slice, wish it were warmer. Think it’s ceiling is 7.9. Great crust

Great taste, setting the bar for Columbus pizza

Crispy crust, fantastic sauce. Big ole slice.