Mimo's Pizzeria

Not picture is the Margherita. Mimo is home to the only Margherita pie I’ve ever enjoyed despite ordering one everywhere because of their looks. Zero flop when settled and may be the best sauce I’ve ever had. Family-owned and operated and straight out of Italia. Cannoli: 9.3

Ordered pizza for 1145 pickup and arrived at 1135 and pizza was already made and sitting on top of pizza oven. After about five minutes of waiting to get said pizza I finally got a chance to try it. Not bad. Little flop. Nice undercarriage. Good NY style slices but still a bit chewy (even when I asked for well done). But this was still a good pizza. Wished I had it when it was fresh and customer service was a little better and I probably score this in high 7s for sure.

Very good cheese pie here. The crust is thin and crispy. The sauce is good. Has a little flop but it’s not a problem. Might be my new spot for local New York style

An amazing New York style pizza with great flavor and crust. It’s family owned and when you walk in, you feel like you are in an Italian pizza parlor. I ordered it well done.

Best pizza in Louisville area trust me I’m a New Yorker and know my pizza. It’s great always good and if ya don’t agree go to Papa John’s

On of the better NY style pies you will find in New Albany.

I went to this restaurant years ago and got the pasta. I don’t really remember if I liked it or not. I have been seeing people saying they have a good NY style pizza so I had to give it a try. Now I have found my favorite pizza on this side of the river if not in the metro area. This is probably the closest I’ve had to the pies I have had in NYC and I will now be a regular. Apologies to my wife for the extra pounds that are coming in the future! The only thing that would make this pizza better is if it’d be from a coal fired oven, but that’s just preference. This stuff is great as is!

Tastes like cheap ass pizza!! According to the app this is the best pizza in New Albany, IN. If this is the best pizza they have, they are in bad shape!

Authenticity of a real New York style pizza... thin, some flop, a little char, overall tasty.. side note: garlic knots 5.5

Great NY pizza. Crisp crust, good cheese. My go to and Mimo is great.

No flop. Great crust. Best pizza around Louisville area. Hidden gem.

I took my large adult son Matt here. He didn’t like it because I wouldn’t buy him wings with the pizza. I loved it though! Matt usually makes us eat Little Caesar’s, so this was a real treat.

Matt Thomas loves wet meat on his pizza pie! A simple man who likes Little Caesars pretzel pizza. Mimos is the best pizza in Southern Indiana by far!

This pizza was trash. It could have been good the crust was almost good. The toppings were swimming in grease. Maybe one bad experience but I don’t think so. Don’t eat this pizza.

A great slice. Thin and crispy.

This is how it’s done!