Been here many times before, but have never done a review. Everything about Modern’s pizza is amazing. One of the biggest reasons why New Haven is the pizza capital of the world.
westham2/18/24, 2:07 a.m.
Was told this is the best of the big 3, still not totally convinced but wow was the cheese solid. Great undercarriage, crisp, and cheese. Not much sauce but as a result the slices are thin and ideal.
mdn2502/15/24, 7:16 p.m.
My favorite of the Big 3. This could have been a little bit more well done but orders were flying even at 11am. Overall my personal preference for best taste in New Haven.
damion.b2/7/24, 2:14 a.m.
Solid Pizza, good undercarriage and fantastic taste. Could tighten up the top slightly.
jmpizza2221/29/24, 6:07 p.m.
Flavor was on point. Crust was crunchy and great tasting. This particular pie was somewhat soupy and did not live up to high expectations as a result. Hoping to try again as had flavor profile to be higher if cooked a little better
pizza.gate1/28/24, 2:44 a.m.
This was the Italian Bomb, unseen is the plain cheese that was gone within seconds. I have found my fav of all time and is honestly the best I’ve ever had. Worth the 2 hour trip. This is a must try. My only 10. It’s perfect.
avery.wyman1/22/24, 12:54 a.m.
Was kinda soupy in the middle and was a heavier pizza. Was still good but not as good as Sally’s
bryan.rathbun1/19/24, 6:35 p.m.
Very good crust and I liked the sauce a lot too. Big fan of brick oven
dankteam1/14/24, 2:38 a.m.
This place was on our list of pizza places to try in New Haven, didn’t really know what to expect but with Dave giving them a great score we had to stop by. Placed my order out back (great idea btw having a separate entrance for takeout) Staff was friendly and got my hot pizza in about 15 minutes! This was seriously the best pizza my wife and I have ever had 🔥😮💨 Super crispy and perfectly cooked. Props to this business and we WILL be coming back very Soon!
brendan.laduke1/4/24, 8:21 p.m.
Just a classic grade A za. Sauce was great, salty and oily. Pepperoni cooked to perfection, bottom of the pizza was a little undercooked for my liking, it was definitely a floppier pizza. Usually my favorite spot but this time around the crust let me down, still an elite slice.
christian_lerro1/3/24, 12:09 a.m.
Stopped in and had the Italian bomb… loved the pizza and the atmosphere . Definitely worth the wait!
littlenero1/1/24, 3:14 p.m.
Disgusting pizza. Don’t understand the hype. I am a big Sally’s and Pepe’s fan so I decided to try this and it was a big mistake. Average pizza. Didn’t like the oregano on the original, pizza was very floppy, and the cornmeal on the bottom of the pizza was not appetizing.