I ordered two pizzas. The first was a plain with grated cheese that was easily a 9.2 the crust was perfectly cooked that had a nice little burn to it but not too much and there was no grease or flop at all. The second pizza I got was their Italian bomb and that was an 8.7 it was a little too messy and greasy creating a flop and pretty hard to eat with your hands, however the overall quality of the pizza was still great. Had to average the scores but I couldn’t quite give it a 9, great pizza.
brian_f5/7/21, 9:20 p.m.
I wanted to like it more than I did. Just a little to sloppy for my liking.
kilty.mcbagpipe5/6/21, 11:28 p.m.
Wild flavor from the cheese. Charred is nice but parts of the crust were so charred you couldn’t eat it. Fantastic pizza, fantastic spot. Loved it.
john.vittori15/1/21, 3:48 p.m.
We were a little late so the pizza was not fresh out of the oven. Damn good pizza still, but not as good as Pepe’s. Waiting for Sally’s now to complete the trifecta.
kyle.gavetti4/25/21, 12:17 a.m.
Greasy pie. Way too much cheese. Clams casino pizza was not for me and I love clams casino.
gbellemare54/10/21, 9:33 p.m.
Amazing pizza Light taste. Every aspect hits on this pizza. Sauce cheese and dough. Great new haven pizza
allrightsethy4/10/21, 8:10 p.m.
We added peppers.It was really really good I would definitely have it again.
boxcarben4/10/21, 6:59 p.m.
Heavy heavy cheese taste - if you like a heavy cheese pie then definitely higher
dream_slice4/3/21, 9:25 p.m.
I like the thinnest of the pizza and the hint of pecorino Romano, but the slice was very floppy. Even though it was floppy, this was a pretty good slice.
billy.k3/27/21, 10:47 p.m.
great cheese, sauce had some zing a little bit undercooked ok bottom but nice flavor
michael.mahle3/25/21, 6:54 p.m.
First trip to Modern and was very pleased. Also got a small Italian bomb pie which was very good but impossible to actually eat as a slice. Tangier and saltier cheese than Pepe’s in a good way. I think we liked the crust better at Pepe’s today as a group but this really hit me good.
erlil3/20/21, 10:10 p.m.
very very good - so far in New Haven we have hit here and Frank Pepe’s... both FIRE but Frank Pepe’s a little better. This is so good. Also plain pizza you have to say mozzarella or just sauce with parm cheese so we did half and half to try. mozz side better.
james.dowd23/17/21, 7:38 p.m.
This pizza was fantastic, a little more crust compared to Frank’s and Sally’s but it was light airy and crisp. Would have scored it higher but it was a little to loose and sloppy in the center. Taste was amazing
cent1743/14/21, 3:29 a.m.
Very similar style to Sally’s and Frank PePe. Solid pie. Little bit of thicker rubber crust, but overall fantastic slice!
danielle.hayden3/14/21, 1:43 a.m.
A little bit more greasy than Sally’s but the flavor was amazing and the cheese was delicious! One of my favorites!!