This one was on my bucket list for a while. Boy, was it enjoyable even though I was expected to be disappointed. The coal oven really gave it great flavor, and the crust was my favorite part. Cheese to sauce ratio was slightly in favor of the cheese, but it didn't take away from that great taste from the seasoned sauce. The only beef I had with the pie was the loose and floppy center. If it had the crisp like it did on the back end, this would be in the high 8's low 9's. May be the best in New Haven, and would return in a heartbeat.
laney.arlinghaus9/17/23, 1:27 a.m.
Super delicious. Waited for about 30 minutes on a Saturday night and got our food within 10 of being inside. Great service and delicious local cola.
jules.cesare9/15/23, 7:50 p.m.
One of the best pizzas ever. Had a medium muzz and a garden salad. So, so good. Will be dreaming about it until I return to New Haven
matthew.doyen9/10/23, 12:47 a.m.
Great crisp on the crust and really good pizza. Wish there was a little more sauce and a little more flavor with the sauce. Overall a really good pie but probably not quite on Pepe level in New Haven.
steven.kanoff9/3/23, 7:44 p.m.
Excellent char, perfect crunch on the crust. Sauce was tangy and had good flavor. The sausage was also delicious and light tasting with a nice fennel flavor. The pizza as a whole lacked a “punch” for me as it did not have a lot of cheese. I would opt for extra cheese next time and the score will probably be higher.
drew.vernon8/28/23, 12:26 a.m.
Photo doesn’t do it justice, legitimately a top 3 pie I’ve ever had. There was a good bit of flop and maybe could’ve been cooked longer but other than that it was close to flawless
john.yelton8/7/23, 11:53 a.m.
Very good slice, a bit better than Pepe’s, cheese is higher quality
tpm128/5/23, 4:27 a.m.
Right up there with Sally’s. The sauce and grated together are a perfect match.
jerrod.gray8/4/23, 9:00 p.m.
Light crust , not as much crunch as I would want but it was good! Sauce and cheese were good!
michael.weinberg7/28/23, 6:27 p.m.
Pizza was amazing. Crust sauce and cheese 🔥. The middle has some flop for sure but it didn’t stop me from moving every bite.