Montana Brothers Pizzeria & Catering

Have passed this place a hundred times going to long beach, but had to stop in today. Very solid sicilian slice from this place. Its a bit on the dense side and not as thick as a lot of other slices, but had a nice under with a solid crunch, sauce was solid, cheese better quality than a lot of other spots. $14 for 2 slices and a pinwheel is a bit steep, but worth it.

Good flavor, decent crisp, overall pretty well balanced. Nothing about it really wowed me though. That being said very good.

My boy just asked me where to get the most mid pizza out there. Brought him here and it really hit home.

The best buffalo slice I’ve ever had.

Fair enough. The rice ball was actually the best part.

Floppy floppy floppy

Awesome pizza. Great crust. Sauce is on point. I prefer the Freeport location over merrick for individual slices. Highly recommend.

Just the Facts: Same as Davies score - it’s REALLY good pizza. So many selections and really good pizza. Only comment is it’s a bit to oily. Overall, worth every dollar you spend here.

Top notch LI slice. The great flavor clearly comes from the quality ingredients. Super fresh…Great undercarriage with a superb crust. It would be hard to find a traditional LI slice that would be better!

Ask for a lil well done and it’s legit fire asf.

The Piazzetta was good. The pizza in window did not look fresh or appetizing. With the flavor of sauce and tasty ingredients I would come back and order a full pie to really test the regular slice. Good crips on the dough.

Great crust, good amount of grease. One of the closest to Queens or NYC pizza I’ve had in Nassau County

Tiny bit of flop. But just came out of the oven. Very good pizza. Good undercarriage. Great sauce taste. Love the cheese. Great LI pizza.

Buffalo chicken slice

Great crust thin and airy very plain reg slice not in a bad way. More flavor to the sauce and this could be 8’s. Would go here all the time If local.

Love the crust, great cheese and sauce

I know PIZZA being in the Food industry for nearly 30 yrs MONTANA BROTHERS IN FREEPORT IS ONE OF THE BEST I’VE EVER HAD !!!

Regular: pretty crispy, sauce is pretty good and cheese is average and didn't give off much grease. My only problem is it has alot of flour on the bottom. All and all it's a decent slice 7.1 Sicilan: really good texture and its very consistent, such a good char on it too . It's a shame because it's way to salty for my taste. That could just be my slice 7.1