Mr. Maines Pizzeria

Cardboard crust, weird sauce

Nice slice

Very good New York style pizza. Quite a bit of flop on my first piece, not as much on the second.

Mids, sauce tasted like dog water, good undercarriage, that’s the one thing I will say. Beach pizza, not NY.

Frankie, that’s a nice lookin pie! Thin, crisp, great crust. Minimal flop, nice undercarriage. ;) Not overloaded with toppings and the sauce and cheese were good. Will definitely go again. Best pizza I have had in the area. Visited because of the One Bite reviews and was not disappointed.

Fire

Have had everything on the menu, Top Notch service and a solid slice! Can’t go wrong at Mr.Maines

Little flop,football pizza

Skimped on the cheese, little greasy, had a little crunch though that’s why it cleared the 5 mark

Guy behind the counter made me a fresh slice.They can make any specialty pizza fresh by the slice if you want. Cheese and sauce was decent nice crisp nice under carriage not to Oily. Not bad over all.

It was just okay, could’ve been a little crispier on the bottom. Flavor was average. Bonus review: garlic Parmesan wings 3.2

Thin. Crispy. Not much flop. Solid slice.

Flop is the best way to describe this pizza. Tourist beach pizza

Amazing crust, the perfect crunch. Sauce was a bit on the light side, but tasty nonetheless. The cheese and pepperoni were both of decent quality, just a tad on the greasy side. I will definitely be coming back and possibly making it a regular.

Greasy, floppy, sauce tasted watered down. The slight crunch gave it a higher score than it should be. 4.2