Mr Pizza Slice

Pretty standard grab and go NY style slice

Great pizza, good fries, good service! Love the sauce and crust a lot.

Basic slice, pretty good but no wow factor!

This joint had some issues in the past, namely the dude slinging the dough but I think they have it pretty dialed in now or at least new guy does. Great ratios and cooked to the perfect temp. Cheese is a little greasy for whinny Dave but I like it. Great carriage and you taste each component.

A generous 6.8

Zero flop, minimal grease, good crunch,

Better than your average Sunday football pizza.

After trying to go to a pizza place on Broad Street that has since gone out of business had to settle for this place. Not at all impressed with the slice. Very basic football pizza but completely forgettable taste-wise. Sweet Ms. Pac-Man machine in the back of the restaurant though.

Best in Monmouth County

Ok pizza not terrible but nothing out of the ordinary

Garbage. The once great MR PIZZA SLICE (once a Red Bank institution) now is nothing but a disgrace to the name. Slice was a soupy mess of grease and horrible sauce, fell apart when picked up, and almost half the cheese slid off. They should really change the name because nothing about this place is reminiscent of the original. The Ms Pac-Man machine in the back no longer works, which certainly seems like some kind of appropriate metaphor for the state of this place in general. Go again? Wouldn’t feed it to me bulldog.

No flop, a little grease, good crunch, needs more cheese

I came here with my boyfriend after he so lovingly suggested that perhaps my attire wasn’t suitable for the original place we were going to go to. Not sure if that says more about Mr. Pizza Slice’s welcoming and casual atmosphere or my fashion sense, but I digress. I got the meatball and the white pizza (sorry, they didn’t have classic cheese out at the time, and i needed to eat!) the dough was very thin with a light crisp to it. I was delighted each time i met up with one of the delectable pockets of cheese. The crust was also great with a crispy exterior and soft, doughy center. Oh, and get the garlic knots too (duh). Overall very good!