Mr Z's

The crust is too flaky, red sauce is good but the cheese is a little dry.

Okay pizza

Good slice

Good undercarriage, stretchy cheese, sauce not to sweet, the crust was spot on. Closest to a NJ/NY pizza I’ve had in Florida in over seven years. Best pie in Key West.

Very good slice. Quick service. Highly recommend!!!

Very good pizza. Solid. Will be back!

It’s good Frankie but get a slice instead of a whole pie I’m still full.

This is their tomato pie. It's built like Charlie's or Vince's in Philly with sliced cheese under the sauce. It's my favorite style pie.

Minimal flop and crunchy, delicious crust that you will not throw away. Quality ingredients and done right. Mike Z and team are great and will not let you down. We ALWAYS go every time we’re in Key West.

Nice and light!

Cheese…7 Crust…8 Sauce…7 7.3 Frankie

Well done and cheese tastes great!

Order by the slice or whole pie. Phillies on point.

Rescore this place!

Best pizza in Key West!!!!

solid slice, decent philly replica. Crust could be better but they’re using florida water so can’t complain. Good

Overload on the cheese .. Crust had a good crisp, but the cheese weighed it down.. If your gonna order a pie, get light cheese and you ll be great!

The absolute best pizza in key west. Thin, crisp, traditional football pizza.

Best pizza not in NJ or NYC. 7.1 is a horrible score Dave!! Be better