Mulberry Street Bay Shore

Out with my sis in LI for the day. The Margherita slice on the right has a good but not great sauce, could be crispier and a fantastic crust! The chicken parm slice was disappointing and floppy with flavorless chicken, it only earns a 6.4.

These meat lovers slices were so greasy. Sauce was good. Good amount of cheese. There are plenty of quality toppings. Then I had a queasy stomach.

Little floppy. Massive slices. Thin! Gotta crisp it up though. Ok taste.

Pretty good , missing something and I can’t figure it out but good

Regular: dough is cooked well. Heavy on the cheese and sauce tastes generic.6.4 Sicilan: cooked well again sauce doesn't taste homemade. 6.4

Good average hometown pizza!

Neighborhood classic. Crispy crust good amount of cheese good sauce. Light grease but so good!

solid texture

Doughy, greasy and had to season the fuck out of it. The cheese could of been better. Not good but also not the worst.

Good slice, nice flavor only wish crust was a little crisp

Margarita