Muscarella's Pizza- Main St. Williamsville

Went to Lancaster location but unable to leave review for them not on the One Bite App. Pizza did have a good taste and crust was my favorite part. It could be a higher score if it hadn’t been so sloppily made. Seemed they just threw the little amount of pepperoni they did put on the pizza. Definitely was no attention to detail when it was made. Would try again and hope they don’t skimp on the pepperoni like they did for this one.

Some of the best pizza in Buffalo. My go-to spot. Consistent, great flavor.

Quite a dissapoitment, as soon as I opened the box the shapes were dis pleasing to the eye, the cheese was sliding down the grease loaded dough leaving behind the bland sauce. The crust wasn’t cooked enough, only thing saving this was the pepperonis which were pretty crisp. Overall I need to flush this flavor out of my mouth or I will be gagging all day.

Alright Frankie Muscarella’s Pizza today. Wow what a downer and waste of money. Let me first of all explain why this is not rated a 0 and that’s because the pepperoni was absolutely fantastic. Other than that though this pizza was basically a slightly glorified Chucky Cheese pizza. The cheese was tasteless and way to much. Every bite I took it all fell off and left me with their terrible sauce and bland dough. After two bites of their tiny oddly cut slices I was done and wanted to regurgitate it. They had crazy New York flop and could fill a whole paper towel roll with grease off this pie. Possibly one of the worst I have ever had and I will not be back. 1.5 for this trash pie.

Dear god Frankie I’m struggling right now to even write this review. One of the worse pies I’ve ever had. First off, wayyyyy to much cheese. Not only that it had no flavor. Same with the crust and sauce... BLAND. Only $16 for this pie and I’m starting to understand why. Dear god that shit was terrible. The only thing saving this from being under a 1 is the pepperoni which was halfway decent. Too greasy and New York flop was off the charts, I’m struggling to keep this horrible pizza in my digestive system. I would recommend that no you stay away from this place. Lousy lousy pizza 🤮.

A really good solid pie

Nice average pie, well done on point

Plenty of flavor here! Again, looks are deceiving but this slice has great flavor, perfect amount of sauce and cheese. This would easily be a high 8 if there was at least some crunch in the dough. No bite, not even in the crust. Flavor saves the day here, overall not bad but I want some crunch!