On one hand the pizza has great flavor and the sauce is great on the other hand it was a soggy mushy undercooked mess. Had it been cooked properly I'd of given it a 7.6 but the way I ate it it's a 6.5
Order now on Slice
Order Mustachio's Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
tileguy1210/2/21, 12:57 a.m.
Tileguy12 here. After a long week of laying tile and grouting, I got super hungry and was craving some pizza. I went to Old Trusty, Mustachios. This place has a consistently cheesy cup and char pepperoni pizza that tastes amazing. It’s got a sourdoughy type cust too. This think is perfectly cooked and just feels so right. If you want a consistent pie and great service get a mustachios.
zahzak9/20/21, 2:01 a.m.
Forgot to take a pic of the pie but that's probably a good thing. Pizza was very bland and floppy. Nothing stood out whatsoever.
zachary.mendes2/25/21, 5:17 p.m.
Soggy pizza, very greasy. Decent price. Gets the job done if you are hungry.
topcheesesnipeslice2/3/21, 9:52 p.m.
It was just ok. I’m a little disappointed honestly. Very light on the sauce, dough is on the puffy side, this one has way too many air pockets.
will.reuter11/13/20, 10:12 p.m.
Stachios pie. Slices heated up in air fryer. Solid pie little greasy always consistent
hydrokilla5/15/20, 8:18 p.m.
A ridiculous amount of cheese on this pizza. Very heavy. Kind of unique flavor but the sheer density of this pizza is overwhelming it’s almost a bit disgusting.
octobereyes4/17/20, 12:57 p.m.
Doughy. Just a little too thick for me. Sauce had no flavor at all. Cheese was the way I like it as well as the pepperoni.
patrick.olaughlin4/4/20, 11:29 p.m.
Really good, a bit heavy and a little greasy but I would definitely order again
drizzz12/4/19, 4:25 a.m.
Very messy. Would have been better with a fork. Cheese slid right off because of it being on the greasy side
andrew.correa10/1/19, 11:15 p.m.
Dough is cooked well, cheese is great, decent crust, a little saucy but great overall taste.
wnyreviewer7/10/19, 12:09 a.m.
Alright Frankie, Mustachios Pizza in Kenmore. Solid Slice of Pizza, not much else to say. Classic Buffalo Style. Good crust, sauce is alright. Just a solid slice of pizza for football!
585rocpizzaguru5/31/19, 3:17 p.m.
Tough one to review. The cheese, sauce and pepperoni are very good but the pizza dough and crust are too soft almost like bread
robc94/6/19, 1:17 a.m.
Very underrated! A good pizza, big fan of the pepperoni. Some may think it may be to greasy, but I happen to think its good. Good crunch to the crust. Big fan of their pie!
buffalopizzaguy10/9/18, 3:33 p.m.
First slice of the day at 11 am. This should be the best slice with it being so fresh. Literally needed 5 more minutes. The dough had the bite of a microwaved slice. Good flavor, great crust but with the bottom being soggy, it killed this slice and score.
bigpapipizzamaster9/13/18, 4:27 p.m.
This place doesn’t mess around, very crispy good crunch and not burnt at all. All around good slice, good amount of grease but sometimes that’s just what the doctors order, not quite in the 8’s club but super close