My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria - Arcadia (Catering Available)

My Slice of the Pie is more than just a pizzeria—it's a journey to pizza nirvana. Their pizza is, without exaggeration, one of the best I've ever tasted in my life. The crust? Absolutely otherworldly. It’s that perfect balance between airy and crispy, with a crunch that is nothing short of divine. You don’t just eat this crust, you experience it—a sensation that stays with you long after the last bite. Then there's the sauce, pure silk in every sense. Its simplicity is its brilliance. It complements each ingredient perfectly, letting the flavors shine rather than overpowering them. And if you think pizza can’t get any better, then let me introduce you to their Elote Flatbread. Eating it is like sitting among the gods on Mount Olympus—it's an explosion of flavors that leaves you in awe. Corn, cheese, and spices come together in a symphony that’s simply extraordinary. In short, this isn't just one of the best pizzerias in Arizona; it’s one of the best in the entire United States. Each slice at My Slice of the Pie tells a story, and it’s a story you’ll want to revisit again and again.

For a NY slice on Arizona it’s a good pie. Good under carriage, good crips, minimal flop. But greasy which isn’t for me It gets a 7.2 because it’s good but it’s not great. there’s nothing stellar about the dough/crust, cheese, sauce. It’s a pretty average pizza cooked really well. If you’re close by it’s a good spot but i’m not about to drive out of my way for it (again).

Best pizza in Phoenix hands down!!!

Probably my favorite pizza place in Arizona. All around great pie, the taste was great cooked very well, zero flop just a really good pie. Also tried their Al Pastor El Blanco and the Elote and they were all Phenomenal probably better than the NY.

Pretty good basic pizza. Some flop on some slices and some firm slices. Crust gets really tough and chewy after a while. If you’re in the area, it’s a good option to get.

It was spectacular!

A bit greasy. Nice, crisp dough. Could be a bit chewier on the inside.

Very good pizza. Crust was perfect mix of crispy yet fluffy. The cheese wasn’t messy and there wasn’t too much sauce or grease. Only reason it doesn’t break 8 is because the sauce could have used a tiny bit more tang.

Small interior dining area, cool vibe, no frills, Pabst on draft. It’s saucy and it’s greasy, both of which I love. Nice crunch to the dough as well. I’m new to Phoenix, but this is the best I’ve had thus far.

Good Solid smaller pizza, no flop but a little greasy. Nice crisp crust with a good char on the bottom. Wouldn’t drive an hour for but if you’re in the area this should be your spot to take a friend. Really cool vibe on the inside

Super greasy... lots of flop Crust is decent

Great crust. A true NY thin crust. Absolutely no flop! Had basic cheese, however looks like they have alot of other great pizza's including carne asada. Solid lunch spot!!!

It is possible that the reviews had me expecting something great. The cheese slice had too much char that overpowered a lot of the natural sauce and cheese flavors. The sauce had something weird going on. There were some bites that were really good and others that just tasted like plain tomato sauce. Overall pizza was just meh. The al pastor slice was weird. Good but weird.

Great flavor combos. Could use a bit more crisp.

great pie amazing owner crispy great sauce cheese is yummy

No flop. Good sauce. Could use a little more cheese but great taste other wise. Good char on the crust. Worth a visit.

Mix of southwest and Italian??? That’s my kind of pie. Best pizza in Phoenix. I got half Carne Asada, half Southwest veggie. So good!

Awesome little spot to grab a slice and a beer. I will be back to try their famous Al Pastor!