Very solid pizza overall. With that being said it was a little greasy but the sprinkled on oregano cancelled it out. Recommend
tommarchiano5/16/21, 12:27 p.m.
Bottom line with this pizza. Don’t come here looking for a traditional slice of pizza, it’s not what they sell. Pizza is made on a conveyor belt system much like Pizza Hut, except this was not as greasy. I came here just to say “I’ve eaten at Mystic Pizza” but to be honest I would eat here again. The vibe was old school, wait staff was friendly and service was quick considering it’s a tourist village. Lots of reviews here calling it trash and I completely disagree, if you’re comparing it to New York or New Haven pizza you’re going to come up with a bad review, it’s just not that type of pizza. For what it is, I suggest you stop in and try it yourself!
pizzaguy1293/29/21, 12:26 a.m.
Coming from long island, have had my share or really good pizza. Hell, even new haven pizza was pretty good. This....this is on par with Chuck e cheese and papa John's. Famously shitty pizza
one_slice3/16/21, 4:22 p.m.
Took a day trip to Mystic Connecticut from New York City and had to stop at this pizzeria because of the movie however the pizza is at best average on a good day. Crust is identical to Domino’s with too much sauce and hardly any sauce. My pie was with Basil but as you can see it looks like a bed of lettuce. Very bland. Living off the nostalgia of the hit movie.
rorygentry3/11/21, 2:03 a.m.
I popped into Mystic Pizza because of the movie and because it was only about 5 minutes off the route of my east coast road trip. The pizza was ok, but nothing special. It was comparable to something you might find at Pizza Hut. Nothing stood out- not the sauce, not the cheese, not the pepperoni... It was a good, but very average pizza. The best part of the visit was meeting the girl from Indiana who was working the souvenir counter. (A fellow Hoosier.) Be sure to grab a Mystic Pizza pizza cutter for a good souvenir- something you can actually use when you get home.
pizzaeater52/12/21, 7:23 p.m.
More flop than Cats the movie. Only thing you can taste is grease. Plus side is a generous amount of cheese on the slice.
mcrobrez12/10/21, 3:38 a.m.
Famous pizza based off the movie, but that is all that it is good for, being referenced by the movie. Very greasy slice, kinda smelly and has a weird cheesy taste and not in a good way. It can pass for school lunch pizza. On the smaller side of a slice!!
easty1/5/21, 7:38 p.m.
I think i’d rather go to Pizza Hut or Chuckie E. Cheese before i go the Mystic Pizza again. just AWFUL.
slicknick351/2/21, 7:55 p.m.
Other reviews are right definitely frozen kinda tastes like papa John
smokingdubes10/25/20, 4:44 a.m.
Meh. Um first how is this a large. Pizza was decent. Do love that cook it well done though!
ian.frons8/24/20, 10:53 p.m.
I misquoted. It’s “You only love me for my dick.” It’s important to understand that for these scorings, I’m not rating the pizza in the grand scheme of pizza. I’m rating according to my own tastes. This pizza should really be in the high 4s or low 5s, but there are random times when I crave pizzas like this. That’s how something like this gets a 6.9 and a place like Bar got a 7.9. In reality, Bar is much higher caliber pie. Anyways, Mystic Pizza in Mystic Connecticut. https://youtu.be/HhFqWgJrtb0
18 views•1 like
mr.mozzerella8/23/20, 8:02 p.m.
Served hot and crispy in 9-10 minutes. Zero flop on the tiny individual slices. There is very little sauce, which is sweet with a little tang. The mozzarella is better than decent and the crust is buttery and crunchy. The dough is in-between deep dish and pizza chain thickness. Overall the pizza is good for what it is. This place is super busy all day so the pizzas are cooked in a conveyor belt type oven like chain pizza places. It’s a good pie for what it is.
brody.boyer8/12/20, 4:52 p.m.
Run of the mill pizza. Kind/fast service but reminded us of digornos.
alessandro.vazzano6/14/20, 6:01 p.m.
Just pleasantly on point green pepper and extra cheese Yummy
abigail.borchelt5/15/20, 11:45 p.m.
Honestly some of the best pizza I’ve ever had, not to mention how accommodating they were during this crazy time ❤️