7.5- great tasting bar pizza. I still prefer a N.Y. slice over this any day. After a Dave’s review I was pumped to try it and it was worth the 25min drive. However Dave has rated a few spots in NY 8.1/8.2 that I would say is Much better than this.
whatispizza54/26/20, 9:19 p.m.
The crunchiest bar pie I ever experienced. No flop- like exquisite tasting card board. With corona, I could not experience the true inside experience that one usually gets with a solid bar pie. Otherwise, this would have warranted an even higher rating.
mike.korybski4/1/20, 11:33 p.m.
Had a bacon and chicken cutlet pie - toppings were on point. We had to get it to-go so it lost some of its crisp. Overall amazing pie.
robert.woods13/29/20, 9:27 p.m.
What is the big deal with this pizza. Yeah it’s good. Love thin crust bar pizza. Not a crust guy but thus had a great loud crunch. But it was a normal pizza. Nothing like what everyone is raving about. I’ll definitely get it again. Maybe I got it on a bad day. Hit or miss. But definitely no where near high 8’s.
pizza_joe3/28/20, 9:42 p.m.
OVERRATTED!! Better than your average NJ pizza but I wouldn’t go out of my way for the pizza again. **For pizza lovers in NJ go to COFFARO’S pizza is south river NJ. Go on a Friday and thank me later** Detailed review below: Sauce = the sauce is dry and hard to taste Crust = this is a very thin crust bar pie. For bar pie I would say this is one of the better pizzas. No grease at all and clean. Nice crunch to the crust Cheese = 75/25 cheese to sauce ratio but the cheese isn’t overpowering. Serving size = I ate the whole pizza in 5 minutes so bigger guys might need 2 pizzas Aftertaste = probably the best thing about this pizza. After slice 2 it started to kick in and it was good Price = great price @ $12.50 Margarita pizza = 7.8. More taste than the plain, but pricy @$22
chris.walsh113/21/20, 9:32 p.m.
Rookie score. It’s not a 7 , but it’s not an 8.8. Great bar pie , glad I tried !
reconjon853/19/20, 2:29 a.m.
Great slice. Told would be 50min until ready. Seemed it was sitting for a few.
mike.buccino2/1/20, 12:58 a.m.
Thin crust. Perfectly cooked amazing crunch. Pizza is plain or topped. It doesnt matter what you get from this place it is easily some of the best pizza ive EVER had the pleasure to enjoy. Amazing little nook in the heart of downtown Rahway!
michael.shults1/4/20, 2:38 a.m.
Ok so the overall is a 8.9 the margarita is a 9.6!!!! For real
35 views•0 likes
cstmharley12/12/19, 10:59 p.m.
Solid BAR pie....wafer thin like a anorexic model thin, good cheese, little hint of oregano in every bite but not over powering. One of the better NJ bar pies I've had... think DP would likey