Napoli On The Bay

Real New York pizza in fl. Great

Solid flavor, could use a bit more crisp. Worth trying.

No flop. Decent crunch. Decent pie overall.

Straight diesel. Great flop, chewy crust. Buffalo chicken is sexual.

Best pizza in the area, hands down. NY style thin crust, fantastic sauce with the right amount of cheese.

Pretty solid slice! Not super thin but great sauce and cheese.

This “Old Naples” Pizza Place is one of the best in southwest Florida. Zero flop, crispy and cooked perfect. Stands up to any pizza in New York and it’s right up there as one of the top pizzas in Naples.

Quite honestly this is the only pizza worth trying in all of Naples. Everyone knows that south Florida isn’t known for its pizza, that being said, this is as close to a NY slice as you’re going to Get. For Naples, it’s the best by FAR.

Wasn’t sure what to expect out of a Florida pizza however Napoli delivered

Great crunch an perfect cheese/sauce ratio

Do not waste your time

From the northeast and I am here for work. For Naples this is probably an 8+ but for someone like me this was pretty average football pizza. A little too cheesy but overall good pizza

It’s pretty meh. Nothing at all stands out about it. Pizza in the Naples area is all pretty terrible and this is o r of the “better” ones. Don’t make a special trip for it!

Great price, great slice! One of the only places In Florida that sells by the slice. Right on the water. Very crispy and tasteful slice of pizza

Solid pizza. Would recommend. Only criticism is that it was very greasy.

white slice gets a higher score but a solid 7.6 for the cheese

Been coming to this place for over 15 years. I consider it one of the best in Naples. In season your gonna wait a little bit but it’s worth it. Not much flop if any usually. Doesn’t matter who’s throwing the pies. Always good. Not flying with the gods in the 8’s, but it’s fuckin close.

This is DAMN good pizza. We had four people try and took the average.

Solid slice can’t complain highly recommend