The real deal. Grandma pie is legit. Perfect blend of crispy crust and gooey cheese. Subtle, wonderful, fresh flavor from the sauce, the cheese and the spices. Had a slice, too, which was solid but not as spectacular as the grandma pie was. They’re doing it right at this place.
jeremy.parcheesi1/8/21, 12:04 a.m.
This review is for the standard cheese slice from the counter. Good crisp on the undercarriage but a lot of flop and some parts doughy at the same time. Decent sauce nothing to rave about. Wish it had some pep in its step. Good amount of cheese. Not bad on the grease. Overall solid NY slice. Recommend when in need of a quick bite like I was. Would like to try again with a pie right out of the oven.
daniel.dorazio9/28/20, 4:12 p.m.
7.5 on the plain slice and 7.7 on the Grandma. Both were pretty good. There were no overpowering flavors and the crust was good on both. The Grandma was very crispy, good stuff.
welltravelledpizzaguy9/24/20, 5:03 p.m.
Good cheese and sauce. Crust tasted a little burnt after they heat the slice back up. Maybe they didn’t undercook it enough for being a slice serving pie. The Grandma Pie on the other hand was very good. I give that an 8.7. Regular cheese, meh. 6.2.
zachary.worthington9/20/20, 7:14 p.m.
I’ve been looking forward to trying this place for quite some time now. The Grandma Pizza always looks so good in the pictures. I wouldn’t say it disappointed, but i was hoping for a little more out of this place. The plain slices looked great but i didnt get one, i should have. The Sicilian was good, cooked well-done, i had to get a slice while we waited because thick crust is my wifes favorite. The sauce could use some work on the sicilian. The dough was great. The well done crispy edges made for a few really good bites. As for the cheese, it was a little rubbery, but was cooked well and i liked it. I’d give it like a 7.7. The Grandma was crispy too where it wasnt cut. The sauce was kind of soupy in the middle on top and it leaked through the cuts into the crust and hurt the crisp factor but everywhere else on this pie was very crispy. It was slightly thinner than i thought it would be. I know grandmas are thin square pizzas but in Ling island theyre usually a little thicker than this. The sauce , other than being too watery, had a nice fresh flavor of tomatoes and garlic. The cheese was ok, kind of rubbery but thats common with fresh mozzarella. I liked it a lot. Much better than most places in the Capital Region. Almost gave it a flat 8. Maybe i’ll update this review after i try the regular cheese pizza.
skyler.jessup6/21/20, 2:54 a.m.
No flop, HUGE slice, really tasty, Big toppings, only had one topping falling off incident, really greasy but overall very tasty. Crispy on bottom, good soft crust. 7.9/8.1 on the edge between seven and eight I guess
beastnipples3/13/20, 10:15 p.m.
Decided to grab 2 pies and average them out for the score. First up the Grandma: Very solid slice. Sauce is light and sweet. Nice crispness on the bottom even though it has some doughiness. Crust is nice an crisp. Good slice of mozzarella on each slice. Taste like they use a garlic olive oil on the dough before the sauce and cheese. Fantastic slice: Grade 8.4 Regular Cheese slice: Good amount of flop since it’s not a super thin slice. Sauce is also sweet and tangy. The sauce is very good. Cheese is solid. It’s a little greasy but not bad. Crust is more doughy than crisp. One side of the pie seems a little more crisp than the other. All in all a very good pie. Sauce is really good but I would like it more if it was a thinner pie with more crisp. Grade: 7.4
pizza_feen2/14/20, 10:39 p.m.
I reviewed (2) pies - Classic cheese Pie - 7.6 Signature Grandma Pie - 8.4
35 views•2 likes
taylorvalente2/14/20, 7:52 p.m.
Best Pizza hands down in the captial region. You could taste the quality in the ingredients.
brett.moore8/20/19, 10:21 p.m.
Always great great crust great selection I visit here frequently for work one of the best in the capital region
angeloj106/24/19, 6:08 p.m.
Awesome pizza, great service. Gotta try “Grandma’s Pizza” crispy. By far the best the have.
andrew.louttit6/12/19, 9:41 p.m.
As far as pizza goes in the Malta area this is hands down the best! Not doughy or under done, sauce has more flavor than another pizza place in the area.
mike.walbroehl5/15/19, 7:35 p.m.
One of the best spots in town, crispy crust, little flop. Not greasy. Could use a little more flavor but very good overall
christerpizza4/5/19, 3:46 p.m.
Very good crisp, almost 0 flop, good tang. Good slice! The Grandma pie is the one to drive for
wadezzeria3/8/19, 2:35 a.m.
Surprisingly, the grandma slice was far superior here... very flavorful sauce... though the crust was a bit thin, dense and chewy... the regular slice had almost no sauce and too much cheese... overall lacking in flavor... regular slice 3.8, grandma slice 6.4
paizan4262/21/19, 6:58 p.m.
Good slice, crispy and then, with a little flop. Good taste to the sauce and cheese. Nice place too.