Nellies Place

Great bar pie

Really good pizza. Thin crisp crust, cheese is a little chewy. Sauce is balanced. Great atmosphere, crazy crowded and lines waiting to get into the restaurant. Solid. Solid pie but not getting anything special.

Awesome bar pie

Not bad. No where near the same level as Kinchley's. Service was a nightmare.

Great bar pie...thin, crisp crust, good sauce, great cheese. Awesome, typical Jersey Pub/Tavern atmosphere. Better than I expected. Not easy to point out, but there is an extra level of flavor that takes it a notch above your typical thin crust bar pie.

Best thin cut pizza, sweet sauce and great bar pie

Better then Kinchley’s, not in the 8’s. Crispy, good taste. Solid bar pie.

Solid bar pie

Very thin bar pie with great taste. All ingredients are of good quality, not salty, not overly seasoned and very flavorful. Would’ve preferred it a little more crunchy but overall top notch.

Not as good as I remember. Way too much cheese for me. Still decent

Well made in the bar style everyone loves.

REAL BAR pie!! The Dave way...

Nellies is a pretty cool NJ bar pie spot. The pie is of course super thin and on smaller side as a bar pie should be. Definitely crushable but lost points for grease and felt like lower quality ingredients. But still not disappointed at all by this.

Dyno-mite!

Not enough sauce and a not enough crisp. Doable but not the winner in the battle of today’s bar pies

I’ll stick with the crowd on this one, it’s good I grew up with it just needs little more crisp

The perfect bar pie