Not enough sauce and a not enough crisp. Doable but not the winner in the battle of today’s bar pies
pfoley571/17/23, 12:16 a.m.
Not bad. No where near the same level as Kinchley's. Service was a nightmare.
rob.rybicki1/7/23, 9:42 p.m.
Great bar pie...thin, crisp crust, good sauce, great cheese. Awesome, typical Jersey Pub/Tavern atmosphere. Better than I expected. Not easy to point out, but there is an extra level of flavor that takes it a notch above your typical thin crust bar pie.
rob.mars12/30/22, 10:42 p.m.
Better then Kinchley’s, not in the 8’s. Crispy, good taste. Solid bar pie.
paulie.pizza11/6/21, 1:33 a.m.
Very thin bar pie with great taste. All ingredients are of good quality, not salty, not overly seasoned and very flavorful. Would’ve preferred it a little more crunchy but overall top notch.
ryan.campbell126/30/21, 9:20 p.m.
Nellies is a pretty cool NJ bar pie spot. The pie is of course super thin and on smaller side as a bar pie should be. Definitely crushable but lost points for grease and felt like lower quality ingredients. But still not disappointed at all by this.
t.woo1/8/21, 9:05 p.m.
I’ll stick with the crowd on this one, it’s good I grew up with it just needs little more crisp
pcheese90116/24/20, 9:25 p.m.
Crust was good and crisp.. the pie was not cut very evenly. It was very thin which i liked but there was too much cheese on the pie. Taste is good but i wouldnt run to get this pie. Mediocre at best.
pizzaguy416/9/20, 5:32 p.m.
Good pizza! I was told that this was the best thin crust in NJ. Definitely isn't. But it's good!