Nelly's Italian Cafe

Tastes great. The cheese all slid off in one bite and lots of slop. If it was a bit crisper it would’ve been in the 8’s.

Tried the regular pepperoni slice. Hands down one of the best slices I’ve ever had so far and that was a single not a whole pizza. The double meat lovers is great too but sauce is on side.

Great cheese great sauce good undercarriage. In the northeast this would probably be a 8.1 but it’s the best pizza I’ve have in middle Tennessee so it gets a bump

This place was packed. They were working hard slinging out good pizza. The cheese was good. They added something extra to the crust I believe I tasted Parmesan. Highly recommend a supreme pizza as they threw on so many good quality toppings.

Crispy and great dough. This is excellent. Tried it by the slice but I’m sure a whole pie would be a few points higher

Prime time

Whoa! Nelly’s really has some good pizza. The ingredients were incredible, though the sauce was lacking a little taste but the pizza was cooked perfect. Some of the best pizza you can have in the suburbs of Nashville. This is Joey‘s son-in-law. So the apple does not fall too far from the tree. Definitely worth a Dave review, but I can see it being hard for him to make it out this far.

This is pretty good, but I do think it lacks that “wow” factor that puts a pizza in the “8 and above” category. The crust lacks a good crunch and the sauce was kind of lacking in flavor. That being said, everything else, from the toppings to the cheese, was really good. It was cooked very well despite the lack of crunch, and best of all, it had had virtually no grease! I’d have no problem coming back here for more.

A bit of flop some crunch a little oil drip. Very good slice

We really like this place. We prefer the Stromboli over their pizza.

Fantastic undercarriage. Cheese is a little greasy but it’s because it’s REAL cheese. Sauce is great.

Solid pie. Best in the burbs.

Always amazing and the people are awesome!!!!!!

Delicious

Tasty pizza not the best but if your in the area definitely worth a shot

Great flavor, crust was crispy in the right spots. Easily killed 3 slices.

Overall a pretty good pizza. Crust is a little thick for my liking and a little tough. Great sauce and cheese.

Solid pizza. A good football pizza with not alot of flop. Crust is good and a little greasy, but still one of my favorite pizzas in Spring Hill.

Best New York style pizza I’ve had in years!

No real flop. Kind of Saboro like but smaller slices. Quality is there but I bet the other items I saw outshine this solid slice. That’s a wrap Frankie.

The little guy said 9.8 but has some to learn... He did nail it - best pizza in Spring Hill. One of the best in Nashville...

Rating is for supreme, NO OLIVES. Canoli was pure Italian bliss.