good slice with great taste crust and flop are a little suspect but great taste
cheeto12/5/20, 12:11 p.m.
Good crisp, solid sauce, toppings have good flavor. Honestly even better heated up the next day.
flaggy11/15/20, 9:08 p.m.
Absolutely bland pizza. The name New York shouldn’t be included with anything when it comes to this pizza. Some of the worst I’ve had. Half pound of cheese, tasteless crust, little to no sauce. Horrendous pizza. A 3.5 is sadly a generous score.
kfein7/26/20, 2:42 p.m.
Last nights pie courtesy of New York Pizza Hilton Head island. By the time it got to me it was a little dry, but that isn’t typical when fresh out of the oven 7.8 @ Hilton Head Island, South Carolina
ryan.sevic7/27/19, 9:18 p.m.
$18 Large Deep Dish Pan — Alright Frankie, this pizza joint looks like it specializes in its name...”NYC Pizza”. However, that have not quite perfected the deep dish pizza yet. There is no flop and the crust is crunchy. The crust is almost too thick to the point where it has no flavor and all of the sauce soaked into it. It is very dry and makes you have to choke it down. The only redeeming qualities are the cheese it is good and 1 slice is so dense that it fills you up. I saw the NY style pizzas going past me while I was waiting and I think the NY style pizzas here looked 10000x better than this one and I seriously regret not reviewing it instead.
pizzaaficionado.ofraleigh4/20/19, 7:31 p.m.
Been coming to this island for 20+ years and if you order just as for well done and you will not be disappointed. Minimal if no flop, great sauce and salty cheese. Always good if you know how to order
sam.tedeschi12/31/18, 3:23 a.m.
It's got decent taste but was a little dense. The crust and dough were kind as rubbery but the sauce has good flavor. Sausage was better than cheese.