New York New York Pizza - Carrollwood

One of the best pies I’ve had in awhile, no flop, crispy. A little greasy but damn good

Been on the list for a min... Multiple locations but a reliable good slice in a pizza-less area

This Tampa Bay Tampa Bay pizza chain is very good very good. 2 slices and a drink for $6? In 2022? Both flavor and value are appreciated here.

This is one of those pizzas that’s hard to write a review of because it does everything right but doesn’t do anything great. But don’t take that as a knock against the pizza, it’s still very good. This is what Dave would call a football pizza. The sauce and cheese are both tasty and the crust is thin. You won’t go wrong getting pizza from here.

‘Grandmas’ In line with what you’d expect from NYNY. Cheese is good, crust is good for Florida, sauce is aight, good seasoning. Always dependable when you want a good slice.

Great flavor with an airy crust! Love the tangy cheese! It’s a little more floppy then what I like, but would order again.

7.7 is way to high for this pizza. No crisp, tang and low quality sauce and cheese

Great cheese slices

Grandma slice is very close to my Delo’s Tomato Pie roots in NJ. Crispy all the way thru very good sauce/cheese mix ...right up my alley.

Grandma slice 7.8 Cheese slice 7.2. Average 7.5. That's a review! Let's go!

Not a bad slice doesn’t have a ton of flavor

No flop, crispy.Could use more sauce.

Very good, sauce is lacking but other than that it’s good

Eat here all the time. Best pizza in the area. Not the best looking. Cheese and sauce are good, nice crust. Some flop. Best choice around

Very good pizza. Best in the area so far. Good crisp and cheese. Moved up the street a few blocks.

Highly recommend just cheese and pepperoni. Huge flop still. Super greasy. Still a fan favorite for Tampa. SoHo NYNY is pretty good as well