New York New York Pizza - Wesley Chapel

Just ok pizza

Little crust, crust flavor and texture is a 7.2 but, but, the flavor of the sauce and the toppings are our top tier. If there was less flop I would have went 8.2. Amazing pizza I would drive 25 mins for this.

New York New York two slices very good I can’t lie. I like the red pie more but the white pie is good. 8.1 red 6.8 white

Ordered a slice of pep and a slice of white. Both were big slices, with well-done bottoms and crispy crust. The slices were rigid, with just a touch of sag at the tip, The mozzarella they used was flavorful and it fairly light on sauce. Slightly greasy. While the crust was crispy and had perfect texture and had good char, it fell a bit flat flavor wise. I would have liked to taste some ferment in there. Overall, a solid slice with great structure. Although, I think it could use a more robust sauce (or maybe just a bit more).

Good quality & taste. Crust was very good and not much flop! Great service and you can get by the slice!

Not horrible. Floppy. Thin.

Little greasy, hell of a flop. Cheese and crust taste good, sauce lacks luster.

Plain. Like 3 pepperoni on a slice, cheese too thin, all tears off in one bite. thing crust. dookie

Basic thin crust pizza. Don’t go after 7 if you want a fresh slice

A little greasy but delicious. Amazing crust.

Nothing to call home about. Best thing was the crust

It’s okay. Too much flop

Everyone knows the rules!

Solid cheese slice, no flop, but the grandma pizza is where it’s at.

Our favorite in the Wesley Chapel area but if this place was in the Bronx, well, it would be out if business. But hey, this is FL and a damn good slice for here.

Not bad, hardly any taste

Good solid slice. Crispy crust, light on the sauce, minimal grease on the cheese, with a half flop hold. Highly recommend.