New York Pizza Co

I have had cafeteria pizza, even frozen is better. They should be sued for defamation for having the name new York in their title. It's five bucks a slice!! More expensive than actually NY pizza too!! Insane! Domino's is better

literally the worst pizza ever. No foundation, shittiest cheese that you have to chew until eternity. The only thing they get right is their Slice pizza, much kore crispier. DO NOT GET A FULL PIZZA; JUST SLICES!!

I gotta say it’s bad probably the worst pizza I had flavor wise the crust is really good (too oily tho) but the sauce and cheese man worst thing I’ve tasted in years

Cheese was amazing, sauce had a good tang. Undercarriage was a little undercooked. Only good fresh and hot

Good, tangy sauce. Cheese is good. Good crust. A bit greasy. Good football pizza. Worth a Monday night football drive.

Crispy crust from center to the edge. Good tangy sauce and cheese. No too salty. XL cheese pie only $10.99. Highly recommended if you are stuck in the I.E. That’s a review.

One bite, everybody knows the rules...I read the reviews on this page I’ve read drunken slice, average slice, bad slice... for me too much flop too much cheese but I’m OK with the grease that’s just flavor. Pat that crap down if you don’t like it. Anyways I would say average slice. Nothing special. You know the car dealerships are just down the street and I could see someone coming here if they bought say a Kia or a Honda Civic and wanted to save a buck from the guilt of buying a new car. Average score is 5.0 that’s my review.

Flavor isn’t bad. Too much flop and too greasy!

Sorry no picture. Good taste. Greasy but acceptable. Some flop. Still searching for real Ny style here locally.

Lots of flop, but incredible sauce and cheese flavor. Crust has some crisp.

I was really excited to order the 24” pizza. But when I got it and saw how they cut it every which way I was disappointed but didn’t let it effect the score. Is this pizza average? Yes. Is it better than every average pizza I’ve ever eaten? Not really. Lots of flop. Lots of grease. Is it football pizza? Not really. This is drunk pizza, if you needed a pizza after the bar closed and your trying to soak up the booze then I could see how this would be ok but they close at 11:00pm. The walk up window and aroma had my hopes up high but as far as pizza goes it’s a 4.7.

Quality similar to little cesars. Crust is pretty tough. Wouldn’t come back here

Too much flop but flavor is pretty good.