lisa.wander7/25/20, 1:28 a.m.
The best pizza in the area. Circumstances and history may give this pizza score a slight edge, but it’s a solid, reliable choice for NY style pizza. A little more tang to the sauce and this pizza would be hard to beat.
robby.wander3/7/20, 8:14 p.m.
Good crisp. No flop. The thin crust, sauce, and cheese all have good flavor.
nteb2/15/20, 2:06 p.m.
NY Pizza Company has excellent pizza. Very little flop, nice crisp and great sauce. Best pizza in Saint Augustine easily.
ydoc318011/8/19, 7:58 p.m.
Think crust with lots of flop. Taste was bland and way to much grease. On another note the garlic knots / sauce were good.
garebear10/16/19, 4:00 p.m.
Ok, Frankie.....New York Pizza Company margherita pie. One bite, everybody knows the rules. A little bit of flop but not bad. One bite....decent crunch.... everybody knows the rules. Really good pizza, not great though. Good flavor, fresh ingredients... decent sauce, not a lot of tang to it... 6.1....