New York Pizza Garden

Coming back to update. Wicked heart burn from this pizza. No better than a frozen pizza. The cheese was dope though. Lot of flour in the bottom. Really rough bite

Little spot me and my brother tried out. Got an XL cheese and added pepperoni. Very thin crust, good cheese and sauce-sorta tangy. Little bit of grease but not bad. Definite flop in the crust though. Maybe needed another minute or two in the oven or maybe we needed to let it sit for a few minutes…it was served straight out of the oven piping hot! My brother lives nearby and said he’d return… good basic thin pizza

Soft/floppy crust and a decent amount of cheese makes a chewy bite, sauce taste good and has a unique flavor, pepperonis had some crisp even mostly being under the cheese

Soft/floppy crust and a decent amount of cheese makes a chewy bite, sauce taste good and has a unique flavor, pepperonis had some crisp even mostly being under the cheese

This place suffers from lackluster pizza, an identity crisis, and it could use a good cleaning. This app calls it “New York Pizza Fish and Chicken,” but their website, menus, and advertising call it “New York Pizza Garden.” No mention of the shawarma. (Maybe they will change the name again soon to add that?) The pizza is mediocre. Not much sauce, kinda greasy, no crispness to the crust. The crust didn’t tighten up any as it cooled down, and the cheese became kind of clumpy. It was ok for the price, but I wouldn’t brag about it or make plans to go back soon. It didn’t take long after eating for me to feel like I had a rock sitting in my stomach. I was there about 10 minutes after they opened. I noticed the chairs and tables hadn’t been squared away, a couple of tabletops were visibly dirty, and there were some large crumbs and trash on the floor. This clearly had to be from the day before, because I was the first person in the door today. If the dining room is dirty 10 minutes after opening, then I wonder what the kitchen looks like?

Sauce is sweet, little tang. Cheese is good, crust could be a little crispier. Overall solid pie....7.1!

Floppy thin crust and gobs of golden cheese just hit the spot. This place is in our regular rotation, could eat it every day!

Needs to be cooked longer and needs sauce

Not good. No crisp to the crust. Soft and doughy. Too much cheese. Not enough sauce. Skip this one.

I tried to like it, I really did. Cardboard crust and almost zero sauce on the pie. 4.6 that’s a review