New York Pizzeria

Pizza was good. Big slices, little greasy but good. Dough was decent. Recommend

ASK FOR EXTRA CRISP great pizza and sausage has amazing flavor over all an amazing slice of pie

It’s not jersey pizza…. Too thick not thin enough

Very tasty. Sauce had a good tang. Cheese was not too greasy. The crust was very good, had a nice crunch but still was soft and chewy.

Solid pizza a bit doughy

Solid New York slice and for $2 it’s definitely worth it. Sauce is underwhelming but the cheese and crust make up for it

Nice and crispy but no tang to the sauce

Home court rookie score by Lanie, but solid pie

Best sauce

Best pizza in town

Decent crust but the sauce is on the bland side.

Heavy on the grease with little to no actual flavor. Best part of whole slice was the crust. Have only cheese slices that they add toppings to as they’re reheated. Better off (and cheaper) getting a pie from the local convenience stores. Order as last resort only.

Best pie in Cooperstown, well worth a visit if you’re in town. Only a 10 minute drive from Cooperstown dreams park.