Order now on Slice
Order New York Sal's Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About New York Sal's Pizza
79 Yelp Reviews
phillypizzaman10/6/22, 6:42 p.m.
Review 319. The cheese slice 6.4 wasnt bad but wasn’t so good either. Very floppy very sloppy had very good crust though. Cheese fell right off..flavor sauce. The square was awesome. That was an 8.5 then sauce was awesome , cheese perfect good crisp very good crust. Overall score 7.5 but get the share tomato/ Grandmom thin slice a little expensive for 2 slices and soda still check ✔️ for good pie
jb123451/7/22, 8:11 p.m.
This is a textbook 6.0 slice. Nothing stood out about it whatsoever, but it wasn’t bad. You went a little too high on this one, Pres.
ben.hanley11/11/19, 2:43 a.m.
Classic NY slice for a solid price. Great crust and perfect amount of cheese
jrzanyc7/29/19, 5:47 p.m.
OK. Staying in Hell‘s kitchen along the pizza belt we have Sal New York pizza... it’s a little hole in the wall it almost looks like a converted $.99 Pizza joint. Extremely no-frills and quite scary looking inside. But I’m not eating the wall, I’m eating the pizza... so on to the review. A little surprised that Prez put this in the seven range. Very generic slice as I stated in an earlier review about Hell’s Kitchen pizza joints... although the Dough has a crispness to it I wasn’t enthralled with the taste... the cheese was pretty good but there was also a lack of sauce and flavor to the slice... it may seem like I’m bashing up it was definetly a decent slice. You won’t spit it out in a pail but you also can walk into 100 more just like it.... 6.5 that’s the review
smash10/23/18, 5:27 p.m.
Tried a Sicilian, regular cheese and pepperoni. All great but the pepperoni was my favorite! Great sauce on this Zaa
greenwood.za10/23/18, 5:25 p.m.
It maintains authentic New York style, but with a little extra sauce. I like that.
john.posca9/8/18, 8:43 p.m.
Very forgettable slices. The grandma was better than the regular, but the sauce had no real taste and the cheese was very stringy
nybasil9/8/18, 4:57 p.m.
Decent. Lacking taste. Good crust & bottom. Needs better quality cheese. I believe it was yesterday’s pie reheated. Had that second day oven smell.