New York's Upper Crust Pizza

Nice cheese and sauce ratio and good sauce. Not enough crisp it needed a little more cook time. Still solid

Ok not has good as I hoped

Pizza was alright, really loved the thin crust and that there is an option for thick crust too. Little greasy. The sauce is very Italian and lite, i dig it. Kinda reminds me of a hotel pizza though, it’s just alright.

Cheese and sauce are good in taste but the slice has MAJOR flop and the crust could be more flavorful. I think this is a very generous score considering how Dave normally dishes his reviews out.

The crust is nice and crisp, but there’s not a lot of sauce and the cheese is okay at best. Nothing special, tastes like something they’d serve at my school

It was alright. The sauce was non existent. The cheese was good but greasy. The crust was pretty dang good. I’d say try it but don’t expect something like NY pizza

Good crust and sauce, cheese seemed old. Still would recommend!

Not bad for the OC

Went big and tried a little of everything. Good pizza. There is better in Orange County though

Needs some more sauce and crispier crust

Ohh! The humanity!!! Best pizza in Irvine. No debate the quality of cheese to crust crunch ratio off the charts.

Not bad, not great. Not too crispy and has flop. Cheese is good but sauce not too flavorful. If it was crispy would of been a 7.

Hands down the best pizza shops in Orange County. Crispy crust on the outside and soft inside, great tasting sauce, perfect amount of oil, quality cheese and other toppings, and good pricing (for OC). Love this location, and the Foothill Ranch location is equally great. Don’t both with any other place.