Nicholas Pizza Shop

Small pies, doughy, crust a little crunchy

I like it

Been around for like 70yrs it’s a local classic. You can only order one size (small), two pies can serve maybe 3 people. It’s got a robust sauce and crispy crust, prob doesn’t need the extra sauce tho. Bonus for being in the unique side.

This is the closest Gluten Free pizza to the original. Nicholas’ Pizza is a local favorite for decades. It is NOT a NY style chewy crust. It’s hard and crunchy. And delicious. Biased score as I have been eating this since my childhood.

Super hard crust! Reminds me of the frozen pizza I made as a kid at home! Gas station pizza is better!

Fresh tomato (only in summer months with tomatoes from Scranton Farms Market)

Terrible chewy/tough crust. Like thick pita bread

Pretty thin pizza, kinda greasy, zero flop. Crust is pretty crisp, cheese and sauce are pretty average, pizza could definitely use some seasoning, but overall not a bad slice at all

Best Pizza in Scranton

Small pie. No flop.

Super crispy! Nice zing to the sauce. Cool vibe inside, been in business for a 60+ years. The owner is the man!

Been around a long time, very good crust.